1. Russel thinks that Descartes was the father of the foundation of philosophy, and he thinks that the fact that Descartes kept testing the foundation of everything made that foundation stronger. I think he argues this by stating that although philosophers were doing what we would consider to be science, they were doing it on no real foundation or basis, and there was no structure and therefore no legitimacy in their work. This statement really shows how much Shorto believes in Descartes work and it shows how much he agrees with it. I don't really agree with Shorto because I feel like Descartes went in a big circle with his "absolute certainty" claims.
2. The main point of Descartes's Cogito Ergo Sum argument is that he can prove only that one thing, which is that he thinks and therefore exists. What he's trying to get across from saying this is that any and all philosophy shouldn't be based off assumptions and should only be based of things that are guaranteed with absolute certainty, like cogito ergo sum. Sort of like mathematics; cogito ergo sum would create a basis and a foundation for all future philosophy, where everything can be proved with absolute certainty and nothing would be assumed. Another thing that Descartes argued for was innate ideas; ideas that only existed within our own minds, ideas that had no outside influence. He argued that these innate ideas were substance, perfection, and sameness. What he meant by innate ideas is that perfection (for example) was something that we couldn't have ever perceived so it came from out minds. I think that Descartes proves his "I think therefore I am" argument quite well; he truly cannot guarantee anything other than that existence without the use of assumptions, but I think that he missed a lot when trying to guarantee innate ideas... especially with the wax example. The flaw there is that the assumption or statement that the damaged wax is still wax isn't innate but in fact based off perceptions from the outside world. One can see a fire and one could have seen what things look like when they melt (like honey) and they could have led to that conclusion.
3. I believe that Cartesian Dualism is essentially the explanation of the mind. It's the only real attempt at claiming the "thought" aspect of it all; it argues that the mind is something that isn't a physical object and it isn't affected by any physical interaction whatsoever, since it can't technically interact. Descartes argues for it by saying that the soul or mind of any physical object is eternal; destroying a cup only destroys the physical aspect of it. The mind-body problem is hell for Cartesian Dualism. It generally is the problem that comes from realizing that the mind has no properties that relate it to the physical body, while still realizing that the mind controls the body. His solution was that the mind and the body were connected through the penial gland in the brain, but this is obviously incorrect since it's a physical object and the mind still technically can't connect with it.
4. Berkeley essentially thinks that we can't be sure that things actually exist; we can only be sure that we perceive things to exist that way. He continues to say that since his perceptions are similar to other human's perceptions, other humans do in fact exist and that they perceive the world the same way he does. His argument is that since our only connection with the external world is through our senses, we can't be sure that our senses aren't tricking us into believing in the outside world. I think that this is a sensible argument, we truly cannot be sure about other things actually existing other than the fact that we perceive other things to exist. The only thing that he really doesn't do well on is the view that other people exist simply because they perceive the world the way he does; he fails to realize that he could be perceiving them that way, and since his only relation with them is through his senses, they could still not be existent.
Tuesday, May 26, 2009
Friday, May 15, 2009
George Berkeley: "Contributions to Philosophy"
1. Berkeley thinks that any given individual cannot know that an object truly is an object, and he thinks that they can only know that the object is a perceived object. He also states that all that we know about an object is limited by our perception of it.
For example (random example) if rocks could talk and we can't sense that in any way, our knowledge about rocks would be that they cannot talk.
2. That they exclusively be understood as perceived objects as opposed to the actual notion that they are real or material objects.
3. He argues that other people only exist because they perceive the same things we do, and since we can only figure out that they perceive the same things we do by first perceiving the outside world, we can firmly put together the fact that they do exist.
4. He argues that other people's perceptions are similar to his own because they communicate the same things that he does. Since he perceived communication and knowledge (as opposed to it being something that a human is born with) and since he's able to communicate with people who also perceive the world in the same way he does since they can communicate, he states that they perceive the same thing.
6. He tried to refute Berkeley's philosophy by kicking a stone and claiming that it existed. However, he failed to refute Berkeley because everything the stone is to him is only according to his senses, and thus, it could not exist at all.
7. Locke thinks that primary and secondary qualities are different in the sense that primary qualities are the actual things, and secondary are the response we have to things. Primary qualities are things that cannot be denied, while secondary qualities are largely opinion based and range in definition.
8. He said that if one stuck one hand in cold water and the other in hot, then moved both to water that was room temperature, one hand would feel as if the water was cold while the other felt like the water was warm.
9. He said that since the size of an object is different to every observer, size is not a quality of the object. I don't understand how he argues for this though; the distance between an object and it's observer don't affect the size of the actual object, but they affect the perception of the size of the actual object, or the secondary quality of it. The primary quality, which is the object's actual size, stays the same.
For example (random example) if rocks could talk and we can't sense that in any way, our knowledge about rocks would be that they cannot talk.
2. That they exclusively be understood as perceived objects as opposed to the actual notion that they are real or material objects.
3. He argues that other people only exist because they perceive the same things we do, and since we can only figure out that they perceive the same things we do by first perceiving the outside world, we can firmly put together the fact that they do exist.
4. He argues that other people's perceptions are similar to his own because they communicate the same things that he does. Since he perceived communication and knowledge (as opposed to it being something that a human is born with) and since he's able to communicate with people who also perceive the world in the same way he does since they can communicate, he states that they perceive the same thing.
6. He tried to refute Berkeley's philosophy by kicking a stone and claiming that it existed. However, he failed to refute Berkeley because everything the stone is to him is only according to his senses, and thus, it could not exist at all.
7. Locke thinks that primary and secondary qualities are different in the sense that primary qualities are the actual things, and secondary are the response we have to things. Primary qualities are things that cannot be denied, while secondary qualities are largely opinion based and range in definition.
8. He said that if one stuck one hand in cold water and the other in hot, then moved both to water that was room temperature, one hand would feel as if the water was cold while the other felt like the water was warm.
9. He said that since the size of an object is different to every observer, size is not a quality of the object. I don't understand how he argues for this though; the distance between an object and it's observer don't affect the size of the actual object, but they affect the perception of the size of the actual object, or the secondary quality of it. The primary quality, which is the object's actual size, stays the same.
Wednesday, May 13, 2009
Descartes Unit 2: Descartes Rising
Since I don't know how to write about the general idea behind the unit without direction, I'm going to follow the instructions posted on what we're supposed to learn while going through this unit. [http://www.madwizard.com/DesRiseInst.htm] I'll go through them generally answering them one by one to the best of my knowledge, even though they're not questions. :) I'll figure it out...
1. Descartes's philosophical method.
His method really revolves around not assuming anything and making sure everything is absolutely certain before moving on to the next thing. Your math example was perfect even though, ironically enough, Descartes thought that math itself wasn't absolutely certain under his philosophy. The whole reason why he does this is because he doesn't want to assume anything because anything later proven with relation to that assumption would therefore be an assumption and not actual proof, so technically, in the end nothing would be proven. He wanted to overhaul the way philosophers thought in this sense, almost like creating a template of absolutely certain things to work off of. Kind of like the "parallel lines" example, though we wouldn't be certain of those according to Descartes. He really aims at proving what already is seemingly true since it hasn't been proved before.
2. Descartes's reasons for rejecting the evidence of the senses as a foundation of knowledge.
Descartes essentially rejects the evidence that senses provide as a foundation of knowledge because they can't be trusted. Since everyone can possibly have different sense, and since senses aren't consistent and since they could be wrong, they can't be used as a basis for founding knowledge. His "Evil Genius" hypothesis expands on this; since it's not possible to prove that our senses are deceiving us, they cannot be relied upon with absolute certainty.
3. Descartes's reasons for rejecting mathematics as a foundation of knowledge.
I looked through your essay and found a little bit on this, but most of what I have to say is what I think Descartes' reasons are. I think that he rejects math as a foundation of knowledge because math is a creation of our senses. By seeing the outside world using our senses, we are able to conclude that there are numerical values. If we couldn't smell, hear, taste, feel, or see anything, we wouldn't really come across numerical values at all, they are a byproduct of our senses. Since we can see, we can see that there are more than one of most things (like our parts that let us see :D) and we create the numerical values which evolve into math.
Math is a human creation in other words, so it can't be of absolute certainty.
4. Descartes's argument for the existnce of one, undoubtable, absolutely certain true fact. ("Cogito Ergo Sum.").
Descartes' whole philosophy actually gets based off this fact alone. Since he can't justify anything that exists using senses, he can justify that at least he exists simply because he is thinking and he knows he is doing so. Since he is thinking, he is something ("I think therefore I am"). Don't get this mixed up though, it doesn't necessarily mean "Descartes" as we know him exists, it just means that the guy who is thinking existed and he knows it, so he exists for sure. Not him as a body, but him as a thought. It's hard to wrap your head around really. ;)
5. Descartes's argument for innate ideas. (The wax example.)
Descartes argues that there are not only things that we learn from using our senses, but things that are innate as well. His wax example is his argument; if a piece of wax was identified as such by how it looks, smells, tastes, feels, and sounds (?), why would we be able to identify it as such when it's melted? Since it looks, tastes, etc. differently, the idea that it's a piece of wax has to be innate.
6. Descartes's further argument for the claim that the senses are reliable after all.
This one's a bit confusing, but this is what I get so far. Descartes (after proving the existence of God with absolute certainty) believes that since God wouldn't create us without the ability to become perfect and since God doesn't allow a "Evil Genius" to roam freely because that would make God imperfect and un-prove the existence of Him, our senses are reliable.
In other words; if God is a perfect being and God gave us senses, our senses must be reliable.
7. Descartes's further argument for the claim that the physical world actually exists after all.
Well this one is pretty obvious. Because our senses are reliable and since that's absolutely certain to be true according to Descartes, the physical world must exist since we see, hear, feel, touch and smell it. Like you mentioned, this is ironic and really puts Descartes in the same position empiricists except for the small notion on being absolutely certain that senses are reliable.
1. Descartes's philosophical method.
His method really revolves around not assuming anything and making sure everything is absolutely certain before moving on to the next thing. Your math example was perfect even though, ironically enough, Descartes thought that math itself wasn't absolutely certain under his philosophy. The whole reason why he does this is because he doesn't want to assume anything because anything later proven with relation to that assumption would therefore be an assumption and not actual proof, so technically, in the end nothing would be proven. He wanted to overhaul the way philosophers thought in this sense, almost like creating a template of absolutely certain things to work off of. Kind of like the "parallel lines" example, though we wouldn't be certain of those according to Descartes. He really aims at proving what already is seemingly true since it hasn't been proved before.
2. Descartes's reasons for rejecting the evidence of the senses as a foundation of knowledge.
Descartes essentially rejects the evidence that senses provide as a foundation of knowledge because they can't be trusted. Since everyone can possibly have different sense, and since senses aren't consistent and since they could be wrong, they can't be used as a basis for founding knowledge. His "Evil Genius" hypothesis expands on this; since it's not possible to prove that our senses are deceiving us, they cannot be relied upon with absolute certainty.
3. Descartes's reasons for rejecting mathematics as a foundation of knowledge.
I looked through your essay and found a little bit on this, but most of what I have to say is what I think Descartes' reasons are. I think that he rejects math as a foundation of knowledge because math is a creation of our senses. By seeing the outside world using our senses, we are able to conclude that there are numerical values. If we couldn't smell, hear, taste, feel, or see anything, we wouldn't really come across numerical values at all, they are a byproduct of our senses. Since we can see, we can see that there are more than one of most things (like our parts that let us see :D) and we create the numerical values which evolve into math.
Math is a human creation in other words, so it can't be of absolute certainty.
4. Descartes's argument for the existnce of one, undoubtable, absolutely certain true fact. ("Cogito Ergo Sum.").
Descartes' whole philosophy actually gets based off this fact alone. Since he can't justify anything that exists using senses, he can justify that at least he exists simply because he is thinking and he knows he is doing so. Since he is thinking, he is something ("I think therefore I am"). Don't get this mixed up though, it doesn't necessarily mean "Descartes" as we know him exists, it just means that the guy who is thinking existed and he knows it, so he exists for sure. Not him as a body, but him as a thought. It's hard to wrap your head around really. ;)
5. Descartes's argument for innate ideas. (The wax example.)
Descartes argues that there are not only things that we learn from using our senses, but things that are innate as well. His wax example is his argument; if a piece of wax was identified as such by how it looks, smells, tastes, feels, and sounds (?), why would we be able to identify it as such when it's melted? Since it looks, tastes, etc. differently, the idea that it's a piece of wax has to be innate.
6. Descartes's further argument for the claim that the senses are reliable after all.
This one's a bit confusing, but this is what I get so far. Descartes (after proving the existence of God with absolute certainty) believes that since God wouldn't create us without the ability to become perfect and since God doesn't allow a "Evil Genius" to roam freely because that would make God imperfect and un-prove the existence of Him, our senses are reliable.
In other words; if God is a perfect being and God gave us senses, our senses must be reliable.
7. Descartes's further argument for the claim that the physical world actually exists after all.
Well this one is pretty obvious. Because our senses are reliable and since that's absolutely certain to be true according to Descartes, the physical world must exist since we see, hear, feel, touch and smell it. Like you mentioned, this is ironic and really puts Descartes in the same position empiricists except for the small notion on being absolutely certain that senses are reliable.
Tuesday, May 12, 2009
Descartes Unit 1: The Method of Rene Descartes [10 Questions on Bottom; General Idea Not Found]
1. Wikipedia misunderstood Descartes by stating that the idea behind the quote was to not only build on old foundations of knowledge but to seek new was as well. Descartes really meant that the old foundations don't let him succeed in his conduct of his life. Essentially, Descartes wanted a whole new way of learning, and that meant not using the old foundation at all.
2. The first is to never presume or assume anything; in other words, if it's not guaranteed to exist, it doesn't exist. The second was to divide up an issue into smaller, more understandable problems, that way everything can be worked at individually. The third was to start from the bottom; choose the easiest and most understandable thing, and whatever you learn from that should be carried on to the next "step", or problem. The final way was to document everything as clearly and completely as possible, in order to make sure nothing's omitted and everything is understood.
Questions regarding Russell Shorto's description of his own book.
3. Generally, it's just like the relationship between faith and reason, either you believe in the scientific method and don't believe in religion or the other way around.
4. The controversy between faith and reason; each side tries to convince everyone that they're right.
Questions regarding the Book Lady's Blog.
5. The Church was threatened because it caused people to disregard what they were originally taught to believe. They were forced to question the unquestionable in terms of the Church.
6. I think she means that it's the way we live now, the way our scientific method is now. I also think she means that modernity is moving forward while traditionalism stays traditional; it's obvious what she believes in.
Questions regarding Shorto's article in the Huffington Post. (You should remember that Shorto is neither a philosopher nor a scholar of philosophy. He gets quite a bit wrong, so don't take his word for everything Descartes thought.)
7. He thinks that it proposes gaining knowledge not through the Bible or kingly power, but instead through human reason... a bit of a fallacy to say the least.
8. I could think of a couple actually. For one, it would affect the masses instead of just focusing on the scholars; everyone can understand what Descartes has to say. Also I think it helps people recognize that Descartes was trying to share his knowledge with the people, which could have been understood in the sense that his knowledge had good intentions. I also think that this could have been away to make a point that he believed in different things than the scholars did.
Questions regarding the video.
9. I think that Shorto interprets Descartes' importance as crucial in forming the modern world; he thinks that Descartes influenced the modern way of thought, where religion doesn't have to do with seeking knowledge.
2. The first is to never presume or assume anything; in other words, if it's not guaranteed to exist, it doesn't exist. The second was to divide up an issue into smaller, more understandable problems, that way everything can be worked at individually. The third was to start from the bottom; choose the easiest and most understandable thing, and whatever you learn from that should be carried on to the next "step", or problem. The final way was to document everything as clearly and completely as possible, in order to make sure nothing's omitted and everything is understood.
Questions regarding Russell Shorto's description of his own book.
3. Generally, it's just like the relationship between faith and reason, either you believe in the scientific method and don't believe in religion or the other way around.
4. The controversy between faith and reason; each side tries to convince everyone that they're right.
Questions regarding the Book Lady's Blog.
5. The Church was threatened because it caused people to disregard what they were originally taught to believe. They were forced to question the unquestionable in terms of the Church.
6. I think she means that it's the way we live now, the way our scientific method is now. I also think she means that modernity is moving forward while traditionalism stays traditional; it's obvious what she believes in.
Questions regarding Shorto's article in the Huffington Post. (You should remember that Shorto is neither a philosopher nor a scholar of philosophy. He gets quite a bit wrong, so don't take his word for everything Descartes thought.)
7. He thinks that it proposes gaining knowledge not through the Bible or kingly power, but instead through human reason... a bit of a fallacy to say the least.
8. I could think of a couple actually. For one, it would affect the masses instead of just focusing on the scholars; everyone can understand what Descartes has to say. Also I think it helps people recognize that Descartes was trying to share his knowledge with the people, which could have been understood in the sense that his knowledge had good intentions. I also think that this could have been away to make a point that he believed in different things than the scholars did.
Questions regarding the video.
9. I think that Shorto interprets Descartes' importance as crucial in forming the modern world; he thinks that Descartes influenced the modern way of thought, where religion doesn't have to do with seeking knowledge.
Wednesday, March 11, 2009
Thomas Hobbes Unit
61. Hobbes thought that humans were mechanical objects; the heart was like a spring, the nerves like strings, and the joints like wheels, and that all of our emotions, desires, and motivations are simply responses to physical sensations. The result of unregulated human beings, when looked at in this model, end up being very pessimistic and quite harsh. Hobbes states that without regulation; things like keeping time, sending letters, and having industry will not work, and that we will fear death at all times. In other words, we wouldn't be civilized if we simply followed our body's "mechanisms".
62. Human nature would be very closely related to human behavior in the state of nature because there will be no sovereign authority to regulate the human behavior from being a direct reaction to human nature. If there was no regulations, there would be no way to lead a civilized life according to this model, and living in the state of nature is like living in a state of war; everyone will act on their own thoughts without any neccessity for justifications or equality.
63. His main justification for the neccessity of a commonwealth is that humans are "unable to rely indefinitely on their individual powers in the effort to secure livelihood and contentment", or in other words, we can't work alone. What we would give up is some freedom; we have to promise that we will secure the benefits of the government by following it's rules, and since Hobbes states that freedom is just going about our lives without interference while respecting other's freedom, giving up some freedom shouldn't be a problem... emphasis on shouldn't. What we would gain is "social and public welfare", which essentially is security of our liberties and freedoms. The reason why they would hand over absolute power is because they agreed to be governed by a single authority, even if they don't agree with it completely.
64. The contracting parties in the social contract would be the people themselves and the government (which is consisted of the people). I believe that the Sovereign will be part of the contract in the sense that it will enforce the laws of it and will give people more incentive (fear) to follow it. It will not, however, be part of the contract in the sense that it will alter or induce alterations to the contract.
65. Hobbes's model of political legitimacy is essentially like the model we believe in now; the government is here for our protection. If a person does anything to go against the laws that protect our freedom, then political authority is legitimate, but if the government does the same and abuses it's power, we can rise against it.
66. No, according to Hobbes, an absolute power type rule (ie monarchy) is the best. He thought that having two or more powers to govern could lead to many problems that threaten the nation itself. Having one power rule all was best in Hobbes opinion, it wouldn't be as complicated.
67. Hobbes thinks that power shouldn't be limited. He believed that imposing limitations on the government would "invite irresoluble disputes over whether it has overstepped those limits", which would be more irresponsible and could lead to war.
62. Human nature would be very closely related to human behavior in the state of nature because there will be no sovereign authority to regulate the human behavior from being a direct reaction to human nature. If there was no regulations, there would be no way to lead a civilized life according to this model, and living in the state of nature is like living in a state of war; everyone will act on their own thoughts without any neccessity for justifications or equality.
63. His main justification for the neccessity of a commonwealth is that humans are "unable to rely indefinitely on their individual powers in the effort to secure livelihood and contentment", or in other words, we can't work alone. What we would give up is some freedom; we have to promise that we will secure the benefits of the government by following it's rules, and since Hobbes states that freedom is just going about our lives without interference while respecting other's freedom, giving up some freedom shouldn't be a problem... emphasis on shouldn't. What we would gain is "social and public welfare", which essentially is security of our liberties and freedoms. The reason why they would hand over absolute power is because they agreed to be governed by a single authority, even if they don't agree with it completely.
64. The contracting parties in the social contract would be the people themselves and the government (which is consisted of the people). I believe that the Sovereign will be part of the contract in the sense that it will enforce the laws of it and will give people more incentive (fear) to follow it. It will not, however, be part of the contract in the sense that it will alter or induce alterations to the contract.
65. Hobbes's model of political legitimacy is essentially like the model we believe in now; the government is here for our protection. If a person does anything to go against the laws that protect our freedom, then political authority is legitimate, but if the government does the same and abuses it's power, we can rise against it.
66. No, according to Hobbes, an absolute power type rule (ie monarchy) is the best. He thought that having two or more powers to govern could lead to many problems that threaten the nation itself. Having one power rule all was best in Hobbes opinion, it wouldn't be as complicated.
67. Hobbes thinks that power shouldn't be limited. He believed that imposing limitations on the government would "invite irresoluble disputes over whether it has overstepped those limits", which would be more irresponsible and could lead to war.
Monday, March 2, 2009
Modern Philosophy Midterm
Here's the midterm. :) I'm fairly confident with it, or rather hardly confident. :P
Oh, and on a side note, I just found out (half way in the test right after the first Okcham question) that I only have to do one question from each section... greaatttt. I'm still including the answers I wrote since I was panicking through them to make the time limit and because I think they're alright. :D Oh well...
Scholastic Section
1. The Scholastic Method was simply a way to "sort out" any arguments or contradictions by taking two things that contradict each other and altering them so they do not contradict each other. They did this by taking the contradictory piece of text in question, which was known as a sentetiae (forgive my spelling), and applying it to either Logical or Philological (again, spelling if it's wrong) Analysis. Logical Analysis was taking the text and applying logic to it in order to reach a conclusion, and Philological Analysis involved altering the meaning of the text by stating that the author meant something else, or that the words weren't phrased properly or mistranslated. This is different than modern thinking in the sense that we're not trying to keep from disproving something, which was mostly religion at the time, and since we're not afraid to accept the complications that come with contradictory things. Now although I'd like to say that I think the Scholastics were trying to do some kind of large scale brainwashing (you know, to keep things interesting), I'd have to admit that it wasn't the case. Scholastics were trying to impose their beliefs on everyone else in a logical manner in order to create one large accepted frame of though, and in doing so they sparked the opposite and gave the blind followers reason to believe freely.
2. Aquinas' views on faith and reason are fairly simple, and it differed slightly from the norm at the time. He believed that reason could be applied to fate, which was unheard of then, instead of there just being a blind following. Unlike the rest, he thought reason was intended to be used, and he thought that faith, with reason, is a much stronger bond. He did still believe that blind faith was okay, which is how I think his ideas are different than now, and he thought that all faith would eventually find reason... which is also very different than modern views.
3. The problem of universals is essentially not a problem of the actual universals, it's a problem of how to make sense of them. The issue is between Nominalists and Realists who believe two different things about the "problem" of universals. Nominalists believe that the relation between two things is a relation that we make up ourselves in order to recognize and organize things in our head. Realists believe that universals are actual beings or entities that we happen to discover. Although I'm not entirely sure, I believe that the weirdest solution was Ockham's Razor, and I think that it weird to thinkers now since they tend to want to chase all leads instead of cutting them out. Let me be clear that this is a wild shot, I can't seem to remember much about this "weird solution", so this is mostly a guess.
Ockhamic Section.
4. Ockham's Razor is a method in which unnecessary or extraneous assumptions can be cut out of a problem or situation in a logical sense. For lack of a better way to explain it, here's an example. If someone was to spot a UFO and claim that it was an alien spacecraft, one could apply Ockham's Razor to reach a conclusion. Since there is a lack of evidence to support the assumption that it was an alien spacecraft, and since that will cause hundreds other unprovable assumptions to be made, one could cut that solution out and go with the more obvious solution; which is that it could have been an unidentifiable object in the sky from this planet. If this was applied to the problem of universals, I think it goes without saying that the "realism" method would be cut away and the "nominalism" method will stay. The realism method of thinking just requires too many unnecessary assumptions to be made.
Galliean Section
9. Galileo's views on the tides were that they were caused by the rotation of the planet on it's axis, and the movement that it makes through space. I think this illustrates his views on the laws of nature in the sense that with this statement comes the belief that the Universe isn't geocentric, also, it illustrates his lack of knowledge about gravitational forces. His reasoning illustrates modern thinking because he attempted to prove it with very legitimate information, for example the notion that parts of the Earth accelerate and decelerate depending on the axis degree. I think this leans more towards premodern or nonmodern thinking because he ignored a severe flaw in his theory, which was the fact that only one tide per day would occur if his theory was true, and instead wrote that flaw off by stating that many various factors contributed to this (none of which were really specified or proved) just so that he can prove something else.
Baconian Section
10. "Natures" are the things natural occurring physical things that we can observe as fact by using our senses. "Forms" are the laws that we observe by seeing the effect it has on natures, which of course, includes ourselves. The "forms" are usually things we can't see alone, in other words things that need a nature to act on, and things that keep natures together (example: gravity, to say the least). These ideas relate to the structure of modern science because even today we separate these two things from each other, for example forms are now called "Laws", and we still don't have an alternative to this structure of thought.
Oh, and on a side note, I just found out (half way in the test right after the first Okcham question) that I only have to do one question from each section... greaatttt. I'm still including the answers I wrote since I was panicking through them to make the time limit and because I think they're alright. :D Oh well...
Scholastic Section
1. The Scholastic Method was simply a way to "sort out" any arguments or contradictions by taking two things that contradict each other and altering them so they do not contradict each other. They did this by taking the contradictory piece of text in question, which was known as a sentetiae (forgive my spelling), and applying it to either Logical or Philological (again, spelling if it's wrong) Analysis. Logical Analysis was taking the text and applying logic to it in order to reach a conclusion, and Philological Analysis involved altering the meaning of the text by stating that the author meant something else, or that the words weren't phrased properly or mistranslated. This is different than modern thinking in the sense that we're not trying to keep from disproving something, which was mostly religion at the time, and since we're not afraid to accept the complications that come with contradictory things. Now although I'd like to say that I think the Scholastics were trying to do some kind of large scale brainwashing (you know, to keep things interesting), I'd have to admit that it wasn't the case. Scholastics were trying to impose their beliefs on everyone else in a logical manner in order to create one large accepted frame of though, and in doing so they sparked the opposite and gave the blind followers reason to believe freely.
2. Aquinas' views on faith and reason are fairly simple, and it differed slightly from the norm at the time. He believed that reason could be applied to fate, which was unheard of then, instead of there just being a blind following. Unlike the rest, he thought reason was intended to be used, and he thought that faith, with reason, is a much stronger bond. He did still believe that blind faith was okay, which is how I think his ideas are different than now, and he thought that all faith would eventually find reason... which is also very different than modern views.
3. The problem of universals is essentially not a problem of the actual universals, it's a problem of how to make sense of them. The issue is between Nominalists and Realists who believe two different things about the "problem" of universals. Nominalists believe that the relation between two things is a relation that we make up ourselves in order to recognize and organize things in our head. Realists believe that universals are actual beings or entities that we happen to discover. Although I'm not entirely sure, I believe that the weirdest solution was Ockham's Razor, and I think that it weird to thinkers now since they tend to want to chase all leads instead of cutting them out. Let me be clear that this is a wild shot, I can't seem to remember much about this "weird solution", so this is mostly a guess.
Ockhamic Section.
4. Ockham's Razor is a method in which unnecessary or extraneous assumptions can be cut out of a problem or situation in a logical sense. For lack of a better way to explain it, here's an example. If someone was to spot a UFO and claim that it was an alien spacecraft, one could apply Ockham's Razor to reach a conclusion. Since there is a lack of evidence to support the assumption that it was an alien spacecraft, and since that will cause hundreds other unprovable assumptions to be made, one could cut that solution out and go with the more obvious solution; which is that it could have been an unidentifiable object in the sky from this planet. If this was applied to the problem of universals, I think it goes without saying that the "realism" method would be cut away and the "nominalism" method will stay. The realism method of thinking just requires too many unnecessary assumptions to be made.
Galliean Section
9. Galileo's views on the tides were that they were caused by the rotation of the planet on it's axis, and the movement that it makes through space. I think this illustrates his views on the laws of nature in the sense that with this statement comes the belief that the Universe isn't geocentric, also, it illustrates his lack of knowledge about gravitational forces. His reasoning illustrates modern thinking because he attempted to prove it with very legitimate information, for example the notion that parts of the Earth accelerate and decelerate depending on the axis degree. I think this leans more towards premodern or nonmodern thinking because he ignored a severe flaw in his theory, which was the fact that only one tide per day would occur if his theory was true, and instead wrote that flaw off by stating that many various factors contributed to this (none of which were really specified or proved) just so that he can prove something else.
Baconian Section
10. "Natures" are the things natural occurring physical things that we can observe as fact by using our senses. "Forms" are the laws that we observe by seeing the effect it has on natures, which of course, includes ourselves. The "forms" are usually things we can't see alone, in other words things that need a nature to act on, and things that keep natures together (example: gravity, to say the least). These ideas relate to the structure of modern science because even today we separate these two things from each other, for example forms are now called "Laws", and we still don't have an alternative to this structure of thought.
Saturday, February 7, 2009
The Six Degrees of Francis Bacon
Hey group :). Here's my answers to the questions. I'm fairly confident with the answers, but there's a few that I'm confused about so please feel free to point those out (it's a learning process :P).
Thanks. :D
1. Natures are the actual events or phenomena of anything that is under the scrutiny of physical science. In other words, the acutal things that the scientists are trying to explain.
2. Forms are the understood rules and laws of the nature being inspected.
3. The Idols of the Tribe are the incorrect assumptions that everything is as we, as humans, percieve it. When humans perceive something, it becomes tained with the fact that it is a human's perception of the thing or phenomena, and not how it actually is.
4. The Idols of the Cave are the inncorrect assumptions that everything is as we, the individual, perceive it. One's perception of any given event or phenomena can be very different than another's perception of the event.
5. Idols of the Marketplace have me a bit confused. It can be either of these two things:
A.) The idols that occur due to a lack in proper communication between people. In other words, one's choice of words can be understood differently by another person. It can also get much worse with translations between languages.
B.) The idols that occur due to the incorrect understandings and presentations that may occur when one perception gets passed along from one person to another. Like gossip, one person can misunderstand another person's story and present the misunderstood story incorrectly to another person who will then misunderstand it.
6. Idols of the Theater are simply idols created by the theater and/or anything related to it. In other words, they are idols that come from the misunderstandings of any given situation due to a incorrect initial belief that was influenced by the theater or any other large influence. It's like making an assumption about something by based off something that one learned from a play.
7. The Table of Presence is the table where all the places or situations where the phenomena is found are listed.
8. The Table of Absence is the table where all the places or situations where the phenomena isn't found are listed.
9. The Table of Degrees is the table where the phenomena's changes in different objects are listed.
10. The Baconian method is fulfilled by going through his tables of Presence, Absence, and Degrees. By simply listing all the things that the phenomena occurs in, all the things it doesn't occur in, and the differences in the degrees between all the things it occurs and doesn't occur in you'll be able to infer what the cause of the event or phenomena is.
11. That Aristotle's logic was still going by the metaphysical theory which meant that everything is as perceived, this is a fallacy or idol to Bacon.
12. I think that it is related to the modern method in the sense that it brought inductive reasoning into play. It paved the way for the modern method by listing what was there due to repeated testing instead of what we think should be there.
Thanks. :D
1. Natures are the actual events or phenomena of anything that is under the scrutiny of physical science. In other words, the acutal things that the scientists are trying to explain.
2. Forms are the understood rules and laws of the nature being inspected.
3. The Idols of the Tribe are the incorrect assumptions that everything is as we, as humans, percieve it. When humans perceive something, it becomes tained with the fact that it is a human's perception of the thing or phenomena, and not how it actually is.
4. The Idols of the Cave are the inncorrect assumptions that everything is as we, the individual, perceive it. One's perception of any given event or phenomena can be very different than another's perception of the event.
5. Idols of the Marketplace have me a bit confused. It can be either of these two things:
A.) The idols that occur due to a lack in proper communication between people. In other words, one's choice of words can be understood differently by another person. It can also get much worse with translations between languages.
B.) The idols that occur due to the incorrect understandings and presentations that may occur when one perception gets passed along from one person to another. Like gossip, one person can misunderstand another person's story and present the misunderstood story incorrectly to another person who will then misunderstand it.
6. Idols of the Theater are simply idols created by the theater and/or anything related to it. In other words, they are idols that come from the misunderstandings of any given situation due to a incorrect initial belief that was influenced by the theater or any other large influence. It's like making an assumption about something by based off something that one learned from a play.
7. The Table of Presence is the table where all the places or situations where the phenomena is found are listed.
8. The Table of Absence is the table where all the places or situations where the phenomena isn't found are listed.
9. The Table of Degrees is the table where the phenomena's changes in different objects are listed.
10. The Baconian method is fulfilled by going through his tables of Presence, Absence, and Degrees. By simply listing all the things that the phenomena occurs in, all the things it doesn't occur in, and the differences in the degrees between all the things it occurs and doesn't occur in you'll be able to infer what the cause of the event or phenomena is.
11. That Aristotle's logic was still going by the metaphysical theory which meant that everything is as perceived, this is a fallacy or idol to Bacon.
12. I think that it is related to the modern method in the sense that it brought inductive reasoning into play. It paved the way for the modern method by listing what was there due to repeated testing instead of what we think should be there.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)