Saturday, February 7, 2009

The Six Degrees of Francis Bacon

Hey group :). Here's my answers to the questions. I'm fairly confident with the answers, but there's a few that I'm confused about so please feel free to point those out (it's a learning process :P).

Thanks. :D

1. Natures are the actual events or phenomena of anything that is under the scrutiny of physical science. In other words, the acutal things that the scientists are trying to explain.

2. Forms are the understood rules and laws of the nature being inspected.

3. The Idols of the Tribe are the incorrect assumptions that everything is as we, as humans, percieve it. When humans perceive something, it becomes tained with the fact that it is a human's perception of the thing or phenomena, and not how it actually is.

4. The Idols of the Cave are the inncorrect assumptions that everything is as we, the individual, perceive it. One's perception of any given event or phenomena can be very different than another's perception of the event.

5. Idols of the Marketplace have me a bit confused. It can be either of these two things:

A.) The idols that occur due to a lack in proper communication between people. In other words, one's choice of words can be understood differently by another person. It can also get much worse with translations between languages.

B.) The idols that occur due to the incorrect understandings and presentations that may occur when one perception gets passed along from one person to another. Like gossip, one person can misunderstand another person's story and present the misunderstood story incorrectly to another person who will then misunderstand it.

6. Idols of the Theater are simply idols created by the theater and/or anything related to it. In other words, they are idols that come from the misunderstandings of any given situation due to a incorrect initial belief that was influenced by the theater or any other large influence. It's like making an assumption about something by based off something that one learned from a play.

7. The Table of Presence is the table where all the places or situations where the phenomena is found are listed.

8. The Table of Absence is the table where all the places or situations where the phenomena isn't found are listed.

9. The Table of Degrees is the table where the phenomena's changes in different objects are listed.

10. The Baconian method is fulfilled by going through his tables of Presence, Absence, and Degrees. By simply listing all the things that the phenomena occurs in, all the things it doesn't occur in, and the differences in the degrees between all the things it occurs and doesn't occur in you'll be able to infer what the cause of the event or phenomena is.

11. That Aristotle's logic was still going by the metaphysical theory which meant that everything is as perceived, this is a fallacy or idol to Bacon.

12. I think that it is related to the modern method in the sense that it brought inductive reasoning into play. It paved the way for the modern method by listing what was there due to repeated testing instead of what we think should be there.

Monday, February 2, 2009

Unit 2 Assignment: Galileo, A Pioneer of Modern Thinking

Hey Group!

I'm sorry it's late, but I had to make plenty of revisions, including erasing the questions and reanswering without quote the text as much. I hope it's still worth something, it took some time! Thanks. :)

1. I think "nominalist" simply means someone who is convinced by the idea(s) of nominalism. I guess it could very well be a way that realists referred to them. It could be someone who has more of an extreme belief in nominalism as well, for instance someone who "lives by" nominalism.

2. I think that Ockham's Razor is the pinnacle (of sorts) of the nominalism ideals. It simply represents a generalist kind of common sense idealism that cuts out stuff that is noticeably unnecessary. Contrary to popular belief, it's not simply ignoring the other possibilities, it's more like ruling out things that aren't necessary or that will require more assumptions to be made.

3. The Universals definitely seem like the one that gets cut away. Just thinking that it's all human made and that universals are human concepts seems like it'd be more sensible then the universals being actual entities, so it'd be the one to stay for sure.

4.
He thought that since mere belief was based solely off human perceptions, it could be prone to error, but that didn't mean he thought it wasn't enough for our needs... he actually thought it would be suitable.

5. His thought that empirical knowledge was important yet limited.

6.
He said that continuing to attempt to "apply philosophical reasoning to Christian Doctrine" was futile, and that the whole idea should be abandoned. I think this is important because it’s the start of people realizing that Scholasticism just doesn't work out too well, and it's people accepting that it's something that cannot be fully understood. It's definitely one of the many steps that led to the end of Scholasticism.

7.
I guess they used Scholasticism to apply their rational methods, but they only did that to create results that didn't make sense or results that were contradictory in order to have people agree that there was no way to apply rational methods to the Christian Doctrine and/or other beliefs. This was important because I think it would have had more of an effect on the people to see someone who they believed in that “believed” in Scholasticism turn away from it and move to Modernism.

8.
I think what he did was try to tell the people to ignore the inconsistencies and contradictions of what came out of Scholasticism by "embracing" it. I think this failed because he actually was blunt in telling people that there were contradictions once it was too late. Since they already knew that there were plenty of contradictions and since they realized that there were alternatives to Scholasticism, having someone admit it that late doesn't seem like it'd convince anyone. Also, it seems like his own words promote Modernism in a sense, and it seems like they could be misunderstood in that manner.

9.
I don't know the answer to this one to be quite honest. I think it was that he disliked that all higher ranked people, or people who held authority, would rule what is right and wrong without allowing any questioning to how they reached their conclusion.

10. I believe his preffered method of inquiriy would be observation and mathmatics.

11. I think this is because a lot of his observations and deductions from them led to controversy that was contrary to popular belief at the time. His move away from Scholasiticism didn't help either, and attacks against it, didn't help either.

12. Being the "Father of Modern Physics" for his contribution "The Two New Sciences", or his other title "The Father of Modern Science" for making observations that changed the course of science permanently.

13. I think that his most important contribution was the telescope and his amazing accuracy in his observations of the moons of Jupiter. The telescope helped pave the way to the heliocentric ideals, which were much better than the geocentric ideals that were adopted at the time, so it definitely ranks as the most important for that reason and for plenty of other reasons.

14. It could have been for a number of reasons, but the most obvious one would be the situation relating the book titled, "Dialogue Concerning the Two Chief World Systems". Galileo was asked by the Pope to write in his book without vindicating or promoting heliocentric ideals and without attacking geocentric ideals. Of course, Galileo actually ended up offending the key person who was defending geocentric ideals in the book.

15. It shows how unfair and biased things were in premodern thinking. Even though Galileo attempted to be rational by explaining his ideas he ended up in prison simply because his ideas were contradicting theirs. Seems like a immaturity/maturity thing doesn't it?

16. Galileo thought that comets were athmospheric phenomena, like the northern lights for example, as opposed to being bodies in space that are viewable through the athmosphere.

17. He said that the laws of nature were mathmatecal, and that everything consists of geometrical figures.

18. Galileo had a theory that tides were caused by the rotation of the Earth on it's axis which caused the oceans to sway back and forth. I believe he ruled out the issues with the theory improperly because he simply wanted to prove that the Earth was moving and that the universe wasn't geocentric.

19. The obvious one was that there were two high tides per day, which is contradictory to his theory which would mean there would only be one high tide per day. He ended up overlooking this major flaw by stating that the water depth and other various factors could have led to two high tides.

20. I'm not entirely sure about this one. I guess it would be a departure from scholastic thinking because he's coming to conclusions using observations as opposed to relying on text to give him the information that he has to conform to.