Wednesday, March 11, 2009

Thomas Hobbes Unit

61. Hobbes thought that humans were mechanical objects; the heart was like a spring, the nerves like strings, and the joints like wheels, and that all of our emotions, desires, and motivations are simply responses to physical sensations. The result of unregulated human beings, when looked at in this model, end up being very pessimistic and quite harsh. Hobbes states that without regulation; things like keeping time, sending letters, and having industry will not work, and that we will fear death at all times. In other words, we wouldn't be civilized if we simply followed our body's "mechanisms".

62. Human nature would be very closely related to human behavior in the state of nature because there will be no sovereign authority to regulate the human behavior from being a direct reaction to human nature. If there was no regulations, there would be no way to lead a civilized life according to this model, and living in the state of nature is like living in a state of war; everyone will act on their own thoughts without any neccessity for justifications or equality.

63. His main justification for the neccessity of a commonwealth is that humans are "unable to rely indefinitely on their individual powers in the effort to secure livelihood and contentment", or in other words, we can't work alone. What we would give up is some freedom; we have to promise that we will secure the benefits of the government by following it's rules, and since Hobbes states that freedom is just going about our lives without interference while respecting other's freedom, giving up some freedom shouldn't be a problem... emphasis on shouldn't. What we would gain is "social and public welfare", which essentially is security of our liberties and freedoms. The reason why they would hand over absolute power is because they agreed to be governed by a single authority, even if they don't agree with it completely.

64. The contracting parties in the social contract would be the people themselves and the government (which is consisted of the people). I believe that the Sovereign will be part of the contract in the sense that it will enforce the laws of it and will give people more incentive (fear) to follow it. It will not, however, be part of the contract in the sense that it will alter or induce alterations to the contract.

65. Hobbes's model of political legitimacy is essentially like the model we believe in now; the government is here for our protection. If a person does anything to go against the laws that protect our freedom, then political authority is legitimate, but if the government does the same and abuses it's power, we can rise against it.

66. No, according to Hobbes, an absolute power type rule (ie monarchy) is the best. He thought that having two or more powers to govern could lead to many problems that threaten the nation itself. Having one power rule all was best in Hobbes opinion, it wouldn't be as complicated.

67. Hobbes thinks that power shouldn't be limited. He believed that imposing limitations on the government would "invite irresoluble disputes over whether it has overstepped those limits", which would be more irresponsible and could lead to war.

1 comment:

  1. Good work. Comment on answer 64: The sovereign isn't party to the contract in that he has no obligations under the contract. He just does what's best for him. Hobbes relies on the fact that peace and prosperity are good for the king to make him work for those things. His whole system is based on the self-interest of everyone involved. That's what's so cool about it.

    ReplyDelete