Tuesday, May 26, 2009

Philosophy Final

1. Russel thinks that Descartes was the father of the foundation of philosophy, and he thinks that the fact that Descartes kept testing the foundation of everything made that foundation stronger. I think he argues this by stating that although philosophers were doing what we would consider to be science, they were doing it on no real foundation or basis, and there was no structure and therefore no legitimacy in their work. This statement really shows how much Shorto believes in Descartes work and it shows how much he agrees with it. I don't really agree with Shorto because I feel like Descartes went in a big circle with his "absolute certainty" claims.


2. The main point of Descartes's Cogito Ergo Sum argument is that he can prove only that one thing, which is that he thinks and therefore exists. What he's trying to get across from saying this is that any and all philosophy shouldn't be based off assumptions and should only be based of things that are guaranteed with absolute certainty, like cogito ergo sum. Sort of like mathematics; cogito ergo sum would create a basis and a foundation for all future philosophy, where everything can be proved with absolute certainty and nothing would be assumed. Another thing that Descartes argued for was innate ideas; ideas that only existed within our own minds, ideas that had no outside influence. He argued that these innate ideas were substance, perfection, and sameness. What he meant by innate ideas is that perfection (for example) was something that we couldn't have ever perceived so it came from out minds. I think that Descartes proves his "I think therefore I am" argument quite well; he truly cannot guarantee anything other than that existence without the use of assumptions, but I think that he missed a lot when trying to guarantee innate ideas... especially with the wax example. The flaw there is that the assumption or statement that the damaged wax is still wax isn't innate but in fact based off perceptions from the outside world. One can see a fire and one could have seen what things look like when they melt (like honey) and they could have led to that conclusion.

3. I believe that Cartesian Dualism is essentially the explanation of the mind. It's the only real attempt at claiming the "thought" aspect of it all; it argues that the mind is something that isn't a physical object and it isn't affected by any physical interaction whatsoever, since it can't technically interact. Descartes argues for it by saying that the soul or mind of any physical object is eternal; destroying a cup only destroys the physical aspect of it. The mind-body problem is hell for Cartesian Dualism. It generally is the problem that comes from realizing that the mind has no properties that relate it to the physical body, while still realizing that the mind controls the body. His solution was that the mind and the body were connected through the penial gland in the brain, but this is obviously incorrect since it's a physical object and the mind still technically can't connect with it.

4. Berkeley essentially thinks that we can't be sure that things actually exist; we can only be sure that we perceive things to exist that way. He continues to say that since his perceptions are similar to other human's perceptions, other humans do in fact exist and that they perceive the world the same way he does. His argument is that since our only connection with the external world is through our senses, we can't be sure that our senses aren't tricking us into believing in the outside world. I think that this is a sensible argument, we truly cannot be sure about other things actually existing other than the fact that we perceive other things to exist. The only thing that he really doesn't do well on is the view that other people exist simply because they perceive the world the way he does; he fails to realize that he could be perceiving them that way, and since his only relation with them is through his senses, they could still not be existent.

No comments:

Post a Comment