Friday, May 15, 2009

George Berkeley: "Contributions to Philosophy"

1. Berkeley thinks that any given individual cannot know that an object truly is an object, and he thinks that they can only know that the object is a perceived object. He also states that all that we know about an object is limited by our perception of it.

For example (random example) if rocks could talk and we can't sense that in any way, our knowledge about rocks would be that they cannot talk.

2. That they exclusively be understood as perceived objects as opposed to the actual notion that they are real or material objects.

3. He argues that other people only exist because they perceive the same things we do, and since we can only figure out that they perceive the same things we do by first perceiving the outside world, we can firmly put together the fact that they do exist.

4. He argues that other people's perceptions are similar to his own because they communicate the same things that he does. Since he perceived communication and knowledge (as opposed to it being something that a human is born with) and since he's able to communicate with people who also perceive the world in the same way he does since they can communicate, he states that they perceive the same thing.

6. He tried to refute Berkeley's philosophy by kicking a stone and claiming that it existed. However, he failed to refute Berkeley because everything the stone is to him is only according to his senses, and thus, it could not exist at all.

7. Locke thinks that primary and secondary qualities are different in the sense that primary qualities are the actual things, and secondary are the response we have to things. Primary qualities are things that cannot be denied, while secondary qualities are largely opinion based and range in definition.

8. He said that if one stuck one hand in cold water and the other in hot, then moved both to water that was room temperature, one hand would feel as if the water was cold while the other felt like the water was warm.

9. He said that since the size of an object is different to every observer, size is not a quality of the object. I don't understand how he argues for this though; the distance between an object and it's observer don't affect the size of the actual object, but they affect the perception of the size of the actual object, or the secondary quality of it. The primary quality, which is the object's actual size, stays the same.

No comments:

Post a Comment