1. Wikipedia misunderstood Descartes by stating that the idea behind the quote was to not only build on old foundations of knowledge but to seek new was as well. Descartes really meant that the old foundations don't let him succeed in his conduct of his life. Essentially, Descartes wanted a whole new way of learning, and that meant not using the old foundation at all.
2. The first is to never presume or assume anything; in other words, if it's not guaranteed to exist, it doesn't exist. The second was to divide up an issue into smaller, more understandable problems, that way everything can be worked at individually. The third was to start from the bottom; choose the easiest and most understandable thing, and whatever you learn from that should be carried on to the next "step", or problem. The final way was to document everything as clearly and completely as possible, in order to make sure nothing's omitted and everything is understood.
Questions regarding Russell Shorto's description of his own book.
3. Generally, it's just like the relationship between faith and reason, either you believe in the scientific method and don't believe in religion or the other way around.
4. The controversy between faith and reason; each side tries to convince everyone that they're right.
Questions regarding the Book Lady's Blog.
5. The Church was threatened because it caused people to disregard what they were originally taught to believe. They were forced to question the unquestionable in terms of the Church.
6. I think she means that it's the way we live now, the way our scientific method is now. I also think she means that modernity is moving forward while traditionalism stays traditional; it's obvious what she believes in.
Questions regarding Shorto's article in the Huffington Post. (You should remember that Shorto is neither a philosopher nor a scholar of philosophy. He gets quite a bit wrong, so don't take his word for everything Descartes thought.)
7. He thinks that it proposes gaining knowledge not through the Bible or kingly power, but instead through human reason... a bit of a fallacy to say the least.
8. I could think of a couple actually. For one, it would affect the masses instead of just focusing on the scholars; everyone can understand what Descartes has to say. Also I think it helps people recognize that Descartes was trying to share his knowledge with the people, which could have been understood in the sense that his knowledge had good intentions. I also think that this could have been away to make a point that he believed in different things than the scholars did.
Questions regarding the video.
9. I think that Shorto interprets Descartes' importance as crucial in forming the modern world; he thinks that Descartes influenced the modern way of thought, where religion doesn't have to do with seeking knowledge.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Good work.
ReplyDeleteI'm not sure what you mean by your answer to question "7. What does Shorto think is the proposal contained in "The Discourse on the Method for Rightly Conducting the Reason?""
You write: "7. He thinks that it proposes gaining knowledge not through the Bible or kingly power, but instead through human reason... a bit of a fallacy to say the least." What do you think is the fallacy here?