Wednesday, May 13, 2009

Descartes Unit 2: Descartes Rising

Since I don't know how to write about the general idea behind the unit without direction, I'm going to follow the instructions posted on what we're supposed to learn while going through this unit. [http://www.madwizard.com/DesRiseInst.htm] I'll go through them generally answering them one by one to the best of my knowledge, even though they're not questions. :) I'll figure it out...

1. Descartes's philosophical method.

His method really revolves around not assuming anything and making sure everything is absolutely certain before moving on to the next thing. Your math example was perfect even though, ironically enough, Descartes thought that math itself wasn't absolutely certain under his philosophy. The whole reason why he does this is because he doesn't want to assume anything because anything later proven with relation to that assumption would therefore be an assumption and not actual proof, so technically, in the end nothing would be proven. He wanted to overhaul the way philosophers thought in this sense, almost like creating a template of absolutely certain things to work off of. Kind of like the "parallel lines" example, though we wouldn't be certain of those according to Descartes. He really aims at proving what already is seemingly true since it hasn't been proved before.

2. Descartes's reasons for rejecting the evidence of the senses as a foundation of knowledge.

Descartes essentially rejects the evidence that senses provide as a foundation of knowledge because they can't be trusted. Since everyone can possibly have different sense, and since senses aren't consistent and since they could be wrong, they can't be used as a basis for founding knowledge. His "Evil Genius" hypothesis expands on this; since it's not possible to prove that our senses are deceiving us, they cannot be relied upon with absolute certainty.

3. Descartes's reasons for rejecting mathematics as a foundation of knowledge.

I looked through your essay and found a little bit on this, but most of what I have to say is what I think Descartes' reasons are. I think that he rejects math as a foundation of knowledge because math is a creation of our senses. By seeing the outside world using our senses, we are able to conclude that there are numerical values. If we couldn't smell, hear, taste, feel, or see anything, we wouldn't really come across numerical values at all, they are a byproduct of our senses. Since we can see, we can see that there are more than one of most things (like our parts that let us see :D) and we create the numerical values which evolve into math.

Math is a human creation in other words, so it can't be of absolute certainty.

4. Descartes's argument for the existnce of one, undoubtable, absolutely certain true fact. ("Cogito Ergo Sum.").

Descartes' whole philosophy actually gets based off this fact alone. Since he can't justify anything that exists using senses, he can justify that at least he exists simply because he is thinking and he knows he is doing so. Since he is thinking, he is something ("I think therefore I am"). Don't get this mixed up though, it doesn't necessarily mean "Descartes" as we know him exists, it just means that the guy who is thinking existed and he knows it, so he exists for sure. Not him as a body, but him as a thought. It's hard to wrap your head around really. ;)

5. Descartes's argument for innate ideas. (The wax example.)

Descartes argues that there are not only things that we learn from using our senses, but things that are innate as well. His wax example is his argument; if a piece of wax was identified as such by how it looks, smells, tastes, feels, and sounds (?), why would we be able to identify it as such when it's melted? Since it looks, tastes, etc. differently, the idea that it's a piece of wax has to be innate.

6. Descartes's further argument for the claim that the senses are reliable after all.

This one's a bit confusing, but this is what I get so far. Descartes (after proving the existence of God with absolute certainty) believes that since God wouldn't create us without the ability to become perfect and since God doesn't allow a "Evil Genius" to roam freely because that would make God imperfect and un-prove the existence of Him, our senses are reliable.

In other words; if God is a perfect being and God gave us senses, our senses must be reliable.

7. Descartes's further argument for the claim that the physical world actually exists after all.

Well this one is pretty obvious. Because our senses are reliable and since that's absolutely certain to be true according to Descartes, the physical world must exist since we see, hear, feel, touch and smell it. Like you mentioned, this is ironic and really puts Descartes in the same position empiricists except for the small notion on being absolutely certain that senses are reliable.

1 comment:

  1. Very, very good! I like your analysis of Descartes views on math. Well done.

    ReplyDelete