Monday, March 2, 2009

Modern Philosophy Midterm

Here's the midterm. :) I'm fairly confident with it, or rather hardly confident. :P

Oh, and on a side note, I just found out (half way in the test right after the first Okcham question) that I only have to do one question from each section... greaatttt. I'm still including the answers I wrote since I was panicking through them to make the time limit and because I think they're alright. :D Oh well...

Scholastic Section

1. The Scholastic Method was simply a way to "sort out" any arguments or contradictions by taking two things that contradict each other and altering them so they do not contradict each other. They did this by taking the contradictory piece of text in question, which was known as a sentetiae (forgive my spelling), and applying it to either Logical or Philological (again, spelling if it's wrong) Analysis. Logical Analysis was taking the text and applying logic to it in order to reach a conclusion, and Philological Analysis involved altering the meaning of the text by stating that the author meant something else, or that the words weren't phrased properly or mistranslated. This is different than modern thinking in the sense that we're not trying to keep from disproving something, which was mostly religion at the time, and since we're not afraid to accept the complications that come with contradictory things. Now although I'd like to say that I think the Scholastics were trying to do some kind of large scale brainwashing (you know, to keep things interesting), I'd have to admit that it wasn't the case. Scholastics were trying to impose their beliefs on everyone else in a logical manner in order to create one large accepted frame of though, and in doing so they sparked the opposite and gave the blind followers reason to believe freely.

2. Aquinas' views on faith and reason are fairly simple, and it differed slightly from the norm at the time. He believed that reason could be applied to fate, which was unheard of then, instead of there just being a blind following. Unlike the rest, he thought reason was intended to be used, and he thought that faith, with reason, is a much stronger bond. He did still believe that blind faith was okay, which is how I think his ideas are different than now, and he thought that all faith would eventually find reason... which is also very different than modern views.

3. The problem of universals is essentially not a problem of the actual universals, it's a problem of how to make sense of them. The issue is between Nominalists and Realists who believe two different things about the "problem" of universals. Nominalists believe that the relation between two things is a relation that we make up ourselves in order to recognize and organize things in our head. Realists believe that universals are actual beings or entities that we happen to discover. Although I'm not entirely sure, I believe that the weirdest solution was Ockham's Razor, and I think that it weird to thinkers now since they tend to want to chase all leads instead of cutting them out. Let me be clear that this is a wild shot, I can't seem to remember much about this "weird solution", so this is mostly a guess.

Ockhamic Section.

4. Ockham's Razor is a method in which unnecessary or extraneous assumptions can be cut out of a problem or situation in a logical sense. For lack of a better way to explain it, here's an example. If someone was to spot a UFO and claim that it was an alien spacecraft, one could apply Ockham's Razor to reach a conclusion. Since there is a lack of evidence to support the assumption that it was an alien spacecraft, and since that will cause hundreds other unprovable assumptions to be made, one could cut that solution out and go with the more obvious solution; which is that it could have been an unidentifiable object in the sky from this planet. If this was applied to the problem of universals, I think it goes without saying that the "realism" method would be cut away and the "nominalism" method will stay. The realism method of thinking just requires too many unnecessary assumptions to be made.


Galliean Section

9. Galileo's views on the tides were that they were caused by the rotation of the planet on it's axis, and the movement that it makes through space. I think this illustrates his views on the laws of nature in the sense that with this statement comes the belief that the Universe isn't geocentric, also, it illustrates his lack of knowledge about gravitational forces. His reasoning illustrates modern thinking because he attempted to prove it with very legitimate information, for example the notion that parts of the Earth accelerate and decelerate depending on the axis degree. I think this leans more towards premodern or nonmodern thinking because he ignored a severe flaw in his theory, which was the fact that only one tide per day would occur if his theory was true, and instead wrote that flaw off by stating that many various factors contributed to this (none of which were really specified or proved) just so that he can prove something else.


Baconian Section

10. "Natures" are the things natural occurring physical things that we can observe as fact by using our senses. "Forms" are the laws that we observe by seeing the effect it has on natures, which of course, includes ourselves. The "forms" are usually things we can't see alone, in other words things that need a nature to act on, and things that keep natures together (example: gravity, to say the least). These ideas relate to the structure of modern science because even today we separate these two things from each other, for example forms are now called "Laws", and we still don't have an alternative to this structure of thought.

No comments:

Post a Comment