Monday, January 26, 2009

The Alternative Participation Assignment

Hello Group,

I'm deciding to answer the questions instead of commenting on the blogs because I wasn't able to think of any comments to post on the blogs (which were great by the way... good job guys) and because the questions are more clear in terms of instruction, but mostly because I couldn't think of comments without feeling like I'd make a fool out of myself. :P

So with that, please go easy on me, the whole study of Philosophy is new to me, so I'm feeling down about that as is. I'm just going to answer the questions in order, and I will post the questions as well because while reading the blog posts that the leads posted I felt the need to go back and read the questions a few times. Here goes. :D

1. What is the scholastic method?

The Scholastic Method is simply taking two similar sources, pointing out any differences between the sources and saying that they are in fact not differences. They'd prove this with through Philological Analysis which is saying that the text itself is not phrased properly or that the writer in fact meant something else, or they would prove it through Logical Analysis which was simply using logic to rule things out and make sense of the situation.

2. What are “sententiae” and how did they figure in the scholastic
method?

Sententiae were simply text of the points of conflict that were found between two texts, they would later be disputed for meaning through the scholastic method. They were highly influenced by the writer of them, hence they're referenced as "commentary", which is understandable and acceptable when dealing with the scholastic method.

3. What was the aim of the scholastic method? What were they trying to
do?

I believe that is was aimed at making things that some may consider unreasonable reasonable. In other words, it was used in order to clear out any disputes over something being stated as unreasonable by someone to make that thing reasonable to everyone else.

4. What was “philology” and how did the scholastics use it?

Philology was one of the two forms of analysis that was used for solving any disputes or disagreements between two texts that had conflicting information. It involved analyzing very specific words and ideas and stating that they were being misunderstood by the reader, or stating that the writer had meant to write something else.

5. For the scholastics, what was the purpose of logical analysis?

Logical analysis is the other form of analysis that was used for solving any disputes or disagreements between two conflicting texts or texts that had conflicting information. This one involved using logic and reason to rule out other ideas, in other words saying that it couldn't make sense any other way than the way that they understand it.

6. Why did Bonaventure think that reason supported the doctrine of
creation?

This one I couldn't understand. The text we were given says, "Bonaventure held that the notion of an eternal material order is contradictory, so that reason itself supports the Christian doctrine of creation." and since I don't understand what "eternal material order" is I wouldn't be able to understand how it's contradictory. Please comment on this if you understand it. :)

7. What did Bonaventure think was our relationship to God?

I believe he thinks that we're "emanates" of God, which would mean that we are sort of a piece of God. For instance, we're all like an aura of God, or some sort of part that is off of Him.

8. What did Aquinas think is the right relationship between faith and
reason?

That would be Theology, or proving God's existence through rational and reasonable means. He believed that they can both coexist and that although faith would be more commonly used, reason or Theology can be used to prove God's existence to those who are more reason oriented.

9. How would Aquinas respond to a situation in which reason
contradicted faith?

I looked through the reading about Aquinas for this one and I couldn't locate an answer. I believe it may be his "Five Ways to Prove God's Existence" that would probably be used to push the idea that since God exist, there must be faith, and that the faith must be true.

10. State the problem of universals in your own words.

This one is tough to explain for me, and therefore hard to understand for you, so please bear with me and point out any obvious mistakes or contradictions in my writing through comments.

To start off, universals are things that put two things in an entity. For example, a cup and a bottle both hold water, and although they're different and their purposes may be slightly different, they are part of that universal. The problem of universals is the attempt to make sense of it all and it usually results in the attacking of the opposing side's argument instead of defending their own, which usually means they don't have a defense.

Some think that universals are actual entities (like water just being water) that just happen to have those two things relate to them. People who believe that are known as Realists, and they believe that everything exists in itself and we just happen to work with it.

Others think that universals are just names for things that don't exist. For example, stating that Sherlock Holmes was a great detective puts him in the universal of detective, but that only exists as a name to sort out what he is, "detective" isn't a living thing or entity, it's just a sorting tool. The people who believe this are known as Nominalists.

11. Describe “realism” in your own words.

Realism would be something that is real and existant. Using our earlier examples, because there are such thing as detectives and water, they are real things that exist as entities or living beings.

12. Describe “nominalism” in your own words.

Nominalism would be the labeling of things. The things aren't real and the names they are given are simply what we refer to them by.


Thanks for reading guys, and if you have anything to say please do, I would love to know that someone actually read through all this. :)) I hope you enjoyed it or learned something new from it. :D

Thanks again!
Abdul Chamas

No comments:

Post a Comment